By its name, Jerusalem is a city of peace (“they shall regard peace”), and for centuries the object of hope for the Jewish people. The yearning to return to Jerusalem was not simply to return home, but to return to God, with Jerusalem acting as the bridge between earth and heaven. The Talmud (Taanit 5a) brings a midrash where God Himself says, “I shall not arrive in the heavenly Jerusalem (Yerushalayim shel Maa’la) until I arrive at the earthly Jerusalem (Yerushalayim shel Mata).”

In essence, Jerusalem is built on two levels: The road to redemption in heavenly Jerusalem goes through its earthly twin. God will not bestow His blessing of peace from heaven until we bestow the blessing of peace on each other here on earth. The Jewish yearning is to bridge the physical and the spiritual Jerusalem, where the angels from Jacob’s Ladder will continue to go up and down, and where it feels as comfortable on earth as in heaven.

Following President Trump’s Jerusalem’s speech, the Conservative Movement worldwide — including 13 of its institutions, the Rabbinical Assembly, United Synagogue, and the Jewish Theological Seminary — issued the following statement:

“Jerusalem is Judaism’s holiest city and the capital of the State of Israel, as the Conservative Movement has long maintained in resolutions and public statements. We are pleased at the President’s initiative, that the United States government will now recognize Jerusalem as Israel’s capital and begin the process of moving the American  diplomatic mission from Tel Aviv.

“The status of Jerusalem is a matter to be settled in direct negotiations between Israel and the Palestinians. But in recognizing Jerusalem as Israel’s capital and planning to move the American embassy to a location under uncontested Israeli sovereignty, the U.S. government acknowledges the age-old connection that Israel and the Jewish people maintain with the holy city.

“We urge the U.S., Israel, the Palestinian Authority, and the international community to take the bold steps needed to advance a two-state solution and a regional accord between Israel and its neighbors. Now more than ever, Israelis and Palestinians deserve a just and durable peace that protects the security of Israelis and grants to Palestinians an independent state in which to realize their national aspirations.”

I believe our movement’s message summarizes and encapsulates the elements that are needed for us to strive for a peaceful earthly Jerusalem. Whether the President’s announcement was simply stating an existing reality, or meant as a will to “undo” the U.N.’s denial of any clear Jewish connection to Jerusalem in its resolution last year, the fact is that Jerusalem is where we have established our capital and we want that fact to be recognized. U.S. policy on the ground reflects an awareness that Jerusalem is a city subject to dual claims, both of which the United States still respects. And that shouldn’t disqualify the U.S. from being an honest broker between Israelis and Palestinians. I hope that other countries and leaders around the world will stand behind Israel and its right to make Jerusalem its capital.

Furthermore, neutrality is not necessarily the best strategy here. For two states to exist next to each other, the Palestinians should grant that right to Israel, too. U.N. resolutions should be calling on the Palestinians to stop their monetary support for terrorists, and stop teaching hate of Israel in their textbooks. Recognizing Jerusalem as the capital of Israel does not negate a Palestinian connection to the land. In fact, the Talmud continues to say that the ultimate obstacle to bridging the physical Jerusalem with the heavenly one is idol worshipping. Since all monotheistic faiths fight against idol worship, there should be no problem in having the Jewish sector and the Muslim sector next to each other.

There is divinity even in this political reality and discussion — a sacred and difficult conversation — as in a marriage. In fact, we say it at every Jewish wedding: “If I forget thee, O Jerusalem, let my right hand forget her cunning. Let my tongue cleave to the roof of my mouth, if I remember thee not; if I set not Jerusalem above my chiefest joy.” That is to say, the relationship between God and the people of Israel is a marriage. There are ups and downs, and we can be away for a long time, but we are still married to each other.

As we enter the month of Tevet, let’s take to mind the lesson of Hanukkah and the candles we just lit for eight nights. At the end of the Haftarah for Shabbat Hanukkah: “Not by might, nor by power, but by My spirit, said the Lord of hosts.” (Zechariah 4:6) Eventually, Jerusalem will show us how to be in peace.

Chodesh Tov.

—Rabbi Gadi Capela